Collective responsibility refers to the responsibility of a collective entity, e. Collective responsibility synonyms corporate social responsibility, methodological individualism, group responsibility, social responsibility, societal responsibility, social intentions, political responsibility definition the ascription to a group or organization of something to be done, of doing something, or of answering to something done. War or aggression is viewed as a breach of international peace and security and collective security stands for collective action by all the. Collective responsibility an overview sciencedirect topics.
If a minister dissents openly, he must resign, or will be sacked. Ministers who cannot abide by collective responsibility are expected to, and generally will, resign. Collective responsibility is not just limited to organizational responsibility, however. The answer to this objection comes from the idea of responsibility distribution. Collective responsibility, armed intervention and the rwandan genocide. Comparison of responsibility and efficacy items in a a baseline model, and b a model in which responsibility and efficacy items are matched with regard to content and avoidance focus to prevent an outcome and are merged in one factor. Collective definition is denoting a number of persons or things considered as one group or whole. Pdf what in the world is collective responsibility. Collective responsibility ngo coordination resource centre. Thus, for example, two lib dem junior ministers resigned in 2010 rather than support the government policy increasing university tuition fees but the five cabinet ministers supported it and kept. Collective social responsibility statement mcinnes cooper. Critical approaches in the context of political science in canada. Collective cabinet responsibility is an idea whose time.
Disagreements should be aired and resolved within cabinet. Collective responsibility stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. Cabinet collective responsibility, also known as collective ministerial responsibility, is a constitutional convention in parliamentary systems that members of the cabinet must publicly support all governmental decisions made in cabinet, even if they do not privately agree with them. Collective cabinet responsibility is an idea whose time has passed. Collective responsibility refers to responsibilities of organizations, groups and societies part of it is the concept known as collective guilt by which individuals who are part of such collectives to be responsible for other peoples actions and occurrences by tolerating, ignoring, or harboring them, without actively engaging. Decisions made by the cabinet are binding on all members of the government. Examples of collective responsibility in practice springerlink.
Five elements of collective leadership non profit news. Is there such a thing as collective responsibility. All members are involved in creating the vision and are committed to working to achieve that vision. The assignment of liability costs could be used to fund mitigation efforts, which reduce the anthropogenic drivers of climate change by either reducing ghg emissions or sequestering those gases after they are. Collective definition and meaning collins english dictionary. Research paper 0482 the collective responsibility of ministers. Collective responsibility also known as collective guilt is a concept in which individuals are responsible for other peoples actions by tolerating, ignoring, or harboring them, without actively collaborating in these actions. Collective security is a device of crisis management which postulates a commitment on the part of all the nations to collectively meet an aggression that may be committed by any state against another. Collective actions, situations, or feelings involve or are shared by every member of a. From this perspective, it might be said that a government or local authority or private sector agency is responsible, for example, for a collective failure to protect. Supporting the path to positive life outcomes for youth in economically distressed communities may 2008. The executive must present a united front to the parliament.
Therefore, if a minister cannot abide by a cabinet decision they must resign. The committee was asked, particularly, to consider the role of a national media campaign in preventing and reducing underage drinking. Collective responsibility beyond business as usual. The only way collective responsibility has ever existed, and can exist given our institutions, is through the agency of the political party. Dec 05, 20 a statement i hear regularly about collective responsibility, is. Although the plagues that god rains down upon pharaoh and all of the egyptians in parashat vaera and parashat bo seem almost grotesquely farcical in their nature blood. In this report, the relevance of collective responsibility and the assignment of that responsibility are clear, and they are best expressed in goodmans voice. This support includes voting for the government in the legislature. This means that if a minister disagrees with a government policy, he or she must. The psychology of collective responsibility 9 this article will explore, from a psychological perspective, the issue of equating collective entities with individuals. Rather than unjustly targeting the innocent, we might say that that the collective punishment teaches us about our collective responsibility to free the oppressed. Five decades of debate in theoretical and applied ethics studies in social, political, and legal philosophy larry may, stacey hoffman on. Collective responsibility house of commons library. Research paper 0482 the collective responsibility of.
Chapter 12 climate change and collective responsibility. The team can then come up with the most optimal solution within these boundaries, sometimes referred to. Philosophical approaches to collective moral responsibility fall into two main categories, individualist and collectivist. What are collective responsibility and individual ministerial. Collective responsibility applies to all ministers and is designed to ensure government unity all ministers have to follow cabinet decisions. Collective responsibility, according to lewis, violates this rule. Shared responsibilty refers to the responsibility of group members for such harm in cases where they acted together to bring the harm about. Definition of collective responsibility by rand dyck and christopher cochrane in their book canadian politics. May himself uses the relational theory of jeanpaul sartre to argue that groups can legitimately be ascribed actions in cases where individuals. The center for law and social policy clasp is a national nonprofit that works to improve the lives of low. Nov 15, 2016 collective responsibility is a fundamental convention of the british constitution, whereby the government is collectively accountable to parliament for its actions, decisions and policies. Collective cabinet responsibility is the convention that ministers agree on policy, and defend that policy in public thereafter.
Ap comparative government britain flashcards quizlet. Another interpretation enables us to derive a lesson from the plagues while preserving the texts emphasis on the collective. In christian theology, the implications of the fall the original disobedience of adam and eve in genesis are variously interpreted. It is exemplified in a report on health insurance on national public radio npr. By rich in announcements 0 0 at collective responsibility, we believe it is our mission to help organizations and leaders move from a position of awareness of challenges to building organizations that are in the best market position to deliver solutions. The decline of collective responsibility in american politics.
Pdf collective responsibility for learning and its. The cabinet ministers are usually selected from the same political party as the prime minister to make collective decisionmaking for legislation faster and more effective. Writing about green social work, dominelli 2012 draws attention to social works commitment as a profession that claims to intervene to enhance peoples wellbeing. Instead, it is a function of the agency of collectives. Joel feinberg, collective responsibility philpapers. Collective action is a subject of interest to people working. The proceeding discussion will argue that a high level of coherence in collective entities. I do so by assuming a particular theory of singular responsibility. Collective responsibility, he says, is a special case of vicarious responsibility.
Collective cabinet responsibility politics tutor2u. Last week, collective responsibility held two training sessions, in shanghai and shenzhen, to help packaging manufacturers in china incorporate sustainability into their products through innovations in design, materials and the production process. Collective responsibility executive luncheon series relaunches this month. Thus, for example, two lib dem junior ministers resigned in 2010 rather than support the government policy increasing university tuition fees but the five cabinet ministers supported it and kept their. Individual and collective responsibility a guide to ethics. Responsibility of every member of a group without regard to an individual members participation in decision making and his or her position or rank. Collective responsibility helda university of helsinki. Based in shanghai, collective responsibility is a strategic advisory firm that fosters corporate social responsibility amongst asias industry leaders. Many contributors to debates over the moral responsibility of collectives have. When everyone is responsible, no one is responsible.
While making a difference in society, we also create a better workplace. Ministerial responsibility is central to the parliamentary system, because it ensures the accountability of the government to the legislature and thus, ultimately, to the population. Cabinet collective responsibility is a tradition in parliamentary governments in which the prime minister is responsible for appointing the cabinet ministers. Npr reporter julie rovner interviewed, among others, john goodman of the national center for policy analysis on the plight of the uninsured on a september morning edition report. In other words, there is such a thing as responsibility for things one has not done. We see our relationship with society and the environment as an opportunity to create shared value. Mean differences between responsibility and efficacy factors in study 1. Collective ministerial responsibility and accountability. Collective definition of collective by merriamwebster. Collective moral responsibility is not a function of the moral responsibility of individuals. Supporting the path to positive life outcomes for youth in economically distressed communities table 1. Ministerial responsibility, a fundamental constitutional principle in the british westminster parliamentary system according to which ministers are responsible to the parliament for the conduct of their ministry and government as a whole.
Global definition of social work international federation. Doctrine of ministerial responsibility oxford scholarship. These statements usually come from managers, who prefer to have a single person who takes the full responsibility so they can hold one person accountable. As a firm, we are inspired by the many stories of how our volunteer efforts and financial support benefit people in our.
A common definition of collective responsibility describes it as unity, solidarity and secrecy. As a firm, we are inspired by the many stories of how our volunteer efforts and financial support benefit people in our communities. See also consensus and doctrine of individual responsibility. The cabinet manual 2011 states that ministers may resign. Having argued in chapter 1 that collectives intentional actions flow from their intentions, this chapter claims that we may therefore understand collective moral. I then argue that collective responsibility, in its various forms, is consistent with this theory. Ministerial responsibility is central to the parliamentary system, because it ensures the accountability of the government to the. Collective social responsibility is not just a way of acting. We define the boundaries to the problem definition by defining acceptance criteria to user stories. Collective responsibility is a fundamental convention of the british constitution, whereby the government is collectively accountable to parliament for its actions, decisions and policies. Collective responsibility is associated with a single. Collective leadership is based on the assumption that everyone can and should lead.
In exploring individual ministerial responsibility, the author recalls some of the wellknown cases of nonresignations by ministers when matters of one sort or another. Collective action is any form of organized social or political act carried about by a group of people in order to address their needs. Pdf the basic bearer of responsibility is individuals, because that isall there are nothing else can literally. Collective responsibility encyclopedia of canadian laws. As indicated in chapter 1, we considered two mass media campaign approaches to affect youth alcohol consumption. Collective responsibility for learning and its effects on gains in achievement for early secondary school students article pdf available in american journal of education 1042. Collective moral responsibility oxford scholarship.
Seumas miller 1998 international journal of applied philosophy 12 2. Collective responsibility for learning and education. No member of the executive can publicly disagree with a cabinet decision. The social work profession recognizes that human rights need to coexist alongside collective responsibility. If responsibility is defined as a bundle of obligations, functional and moral, associated with a role, then accountability might be defined as blaming or crediting someone for an actionnormally an action associated with a recognized responsibility. The international definition of social work also highlights this. Rule that every member who participates or is supposed to participate in a decision making group is 1 equally responsible for the consequences of the decisions taken, 2 should fully support and abide by the groups decisions whether or not he or she participated in the decision making process. The rest of us will bear that burden either through taxes or higher medical bills.
The paper examines both the historical development and. The collective responsibility of ministers an outline of the issues this paper offers an introduction to the convention of collective cabinet, or ministerial, responsibility and explores in general terms this important constitutional topic. An example of collective responsibility, with a focus on collective guilt, is the christian doctrine of original sin. Collective responsibility is a constitutional convention, rather than a constitutional requirement. In this chapter, collective responsibility is first discussed by illustrating the three traditional branches of the collective responsibility convention. Academic commentators have identified three implications of the convention. Collective punishment and collective responsibility my. There is a widespread assumption that responsibility in health care is vested in the last resort in the individual doctor who is caring for a given patient. Collective responsibility regulates the lives of ministers, individual responsibility the lives of officials,none more so than deputy ministers. The conception of responsibility that i have in mind is, i believe, the best and the most appropriate for our time. This chapter explains, motivates, and defends a collectivist account of collective moral responsibility.
The idea of collective responsibility highlights the reality that individual human rights can only be realized on a daytoday basis if people take responsibility for each other and the environment, and the importance of creating. In collective leadership, there is shared responsibility and decision making, accountability, and authentic engagement. In theory, we might defend the traditional principle of collective responsibility as a cornerstone of accountable. Downie 1982 journal of medicine and philosophy 7 1. Together these principles of accountability define an individualistic conception of moral. Collective responsibility in canada collective responsibility.
Collective cabinet responsibility is an idea whose time has. This principle is mainly based on a body of constitutional conventions, established by precedents, rather than on positive statutes. Five decades of debate in theoretical and applied ethics. Profile of youthdistressed cities % children % homicide violent teen % adults below victims under crime pregnancy graduation without % teens poverty1 age 242 rate3 rate4 rate5 diploma6 unemployed7.
1180 1413 186 101 312 159 1012 362 1404 196 1505 156 312 855 944 475 448 1526 1247 1168 741 1168 1518 1209 549 1501 922 450 1085 1372 572 106 801 1280 806 729 510 761 1494 22 92